A Godly Vote in an Earthly City

0
170
Augustine’s “The City of God Against the Pagans” sets a good standard for American voters when candidates are less-than-ideal. (Photo: Mary Cavanna)

“When offered a choice between two politically intolerable alternatives, it is important to choose neither,” claimed Alasdair MacIntyre — a philosophy professor at Notre Dame — just before the 2008 presidential election.

In his essay “The Only Vote Worth Casting in November” MacIntyre argued that because both the Democratic and Republican parties supported policies opposing Catholic Social Teaching, the political system “presents us only with unacceptable alternatives.” He said that “the way to vote against the system is not to vote.”

The principles of Catholic Social Teaching were first introduced by Pope Leo XIII in his 1891 encyclical “Rerum novarum” (“On the Condition of Labor”).

The encyclical states that the century before, when the rights of the working classes were being threatened, “the Church very courageously came to their defence by proclaiming the sacrosanct rights of the worker as a person.” It states that when any “category of persons is being oppressed in the fundamental right to life, the Church feels in duty bound to speak out with the same courage on behalf of those who have no voice.”

Pope JPII quoted “Rerum novarum” in his encyclical “Evangelium Vitae,” adding that it is our duty as Christians to preach the Gospel of life and “to serve it with the various programmes and structures which support and promote life.”

In spite of these teachings, many Catholics today still hold onto MacIntyre’s sentiments.

According to EWTN News, as of 2022, roughly 46.5 million American Catholics are of voting age, and yet only 30 million are registered to vote. This means only an estimated 64% of Catholics are registered voters, and voter turnout year-to-year always varies.

I myself have met Catholics with a broad range of opinions when it comes to political involvement. While plenty of them have stated they vote in every election for the most pro-life candidate, there are also many who say that because the candidate who is “the most pro-life” typically isn’t supportive of federal restrictions on abortion the way many Catholics would like, they refrain from voting at all. Reminiscent of MacIntyre’s position, they claim that voting for “the lesser of two evils” is not worth their time. Some even regard it as sinful.

There are also those who say that their position as a Catholic leaves them indifferent to worldly issues. For them, being “not of the world” means not engaging in it either.

St. Augustine is an exemplary figure to turn to when faced with these matters. In his “City of God Against the Pagans,” Augustine makes a clear distinction between his idea of the “two cities.” These cities — the heavenly city and the earthly city — served two different purposes for Augustine. The heavenly city was perfectly ruled and united by God himself. Augustine wrote that the earthly city would never reach the same level of perfection, as it is ruled by man and exists only in an imperfect world.

Because Augustine was not under the illusion that a city ruled by man would ever be perfect, he was able to engage it as someone, while not of the world, in the world. Augustine famously claimed that the job of the politician — and the state as a whole — was to strive for temporal peace and earthly justice, while his job as a bishop — and the job of the Church as a whole — was to serve the people spiritually. Augustine was concerned about the souls and spiritual healing of the people, while the magistrate enacted earthly punishment.

The separation between the two cities was — for Augustine — a given, and it did not stop him from participating in the earthly, all while striving for the heavenly.

EWTN News says that Catholics of voting age make up for about 22% of the United States’ population, which would be a very significant voting block if utilized. And yet, Catholic indifference and refusal to vote for the most moral candidate on the ballot, is ultimately what prevents Catholic morality from properly influencing the political sphere, sometimes not allowing it to enter at all.

“The Church is the body of Christ, who reigns as king over all Creation. Everything, including political life, belongs to Jesus Christ,” stated Pope Francis in “Evangelii Gaudium” — quoting the 2007 “Aparecida Document” released by Fifth General Conference of the Bishops of Latin America and the Caribbean — “and so participation in political life belongs to the mission of the Church.”

He says: “Our mandate is to ‘go into all the world and proclaim the good news to the whole creation’ (Mk 16:15) […] ‘the creation’ refers to every aspect of human life [therefore] nothing human can be alien to it.”

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here